So you want to Work as a Non-Profit Executive…

Given my line of work, I am frequently asked to meet with senior-level executives who are either in transition or thinking about making a career move.  Usually, they are people who are referred to me by people I already know and they are often executives who have had outstanding, successful careers.

 

I always ask them a very direct question at some point in these meetings – “Have you decided what you want to do next in your career?”  Most everyone has given the question some serious thought before meeting with me and they usually have a handful of options they are considering.

 

More often than not, one of those options is taking their considerable success and skill in the for-profit sector and applying it to the non-profit sector.  Viewed as a way of “giving back,” this idea positively fascinates many executives.  They imagine they will bring a set of skills that will make a sleepy non-profit organization turn into a high-performing machine conquering whatever problem it was created to fix.

 

While certainly admirable and noble, my experience with people transitioning from the for-profit to the non-profit world is this: it is far more difficult than you might expect.  Most executives have a mental picture of non-profit life that is inaccurate and outdated – they expect to find people in leadership roles who are completely devoted to whatever cause they have embraced but who know little about management.  That may have once been true, but it certainly is not true today.

 

So, when I hear executives embrace this idea of transitioning to a non-profit, I always do a reality check with them.  Here are the things I tell them, all of which I have observed repeatedly in my role as a non-profit board director as well as during my early career in non-profits.

 

  • As a business executive, you must think about the opinions and needs of customers, investors, employees and, sometimes, regulators.  A non-profit executive has a much larger group of shareholders to answer to: community members, funders, board members, clients, government agencies, media, employees – the list goes on and on.  And since it is a non-profit, everyone usually thinks they have the right to be heard.
  • If you think you were a hero in your corporate gig when you cut your budget by 10% while increasing sales by 5%, you should know that is child’s play in the non-profit world.  This is a sector that defined the concept of doing more with less. 
  • When things go badly in a for-profit company, the consequences can be serious, but not necessarily life threatening.  If you choose to get involved in issues such as addiction, abuse, homelessness, poverty and the like, making a mistake can cost a life.
  • Contrary to popular belief, non-profits are famously and relentlessly competitive with each other.  They are fighting for miniscule resources and seldom see the value in cooperation.  I believe it is much easier for a company to buy and integrate a second-level competitor than it is for two $500,000 non-profits to combine forces.
  • How do you feel about asking people for money?  If you are going to be a successful executive in a non-profit, you are going to spend a great deal of time trying to separate people, corporations and foundations from their money.  And you have to do this without having a tangible, valuable product or service to trade as you did in the corporate world.
  • And speaking of money, you are going to make about half of what you expect to make in the non-profit world – which is about 25% of what you are actually worth.

 

So, how can you make the leap from the for-profit to the non-profit world successfully?  Here are a few tips:

 

  • Join a non-profit board of directors and chair a critical committee such as finance or fundraising.  This will give you an inside look at how things work.  It will be less helpful if you simply join the board without chairing a committee.
  • Take on an important project for a non-profit organization as a volunteer.  Make sure it is truly meaningful to the organization and involves several stakeholder groups.
  • Join a fundraising committee for a non-profit.  Go out and ask people for donations. 

 

There is no question that a senior role in a non-profit organization can be very fulfilling and energizing.  Proceeding with caution rather than jumping into the deep end of the pool will make it all the more rewarding.

John Salveson
John brings more than 30 years of experience consulting with a broad range of organizations, including life sciences and pharmaceutical companies, banks, insurance companies, manufacturers, professional service firms, healthcare providers, retailers, service organizations and non-profit institutions. John helps companies define their talent needs and execute creative strategies to recruit and retain that talent.

2 Responses to 'So you want to Work as a Non-Profit Executive…'

  1. Marc Miller says:

    When people make the transition to the educational or non-profit worlds it is based on who they envision this environment to be rather than on facts. After a near fatal bicycle accident in 2002, I left the corporate world to teach high school at an inner city high school. I was 46 years old at the time. I was approached frequently from people who said they wanted to do the same thing when they retired. Who were these people:
    Mostly white
    educated
    middle class
    suburban raised
    they knew who their parents were

    After you go through a certification program where do you get hired:
    Inner city school
    poverty
    Minority Majority populations
    single parent households

    I taught for two years at this kind of school and it was extremely rewarding but I could not teach and stay healthy. If you take this path you have to go in with your eyes wide open. It rarely be like the school you went to as a youth.

    After I left teaching I spent a year building a corporate fundraising program for a large non-profit. What they did not understand was companies have budget cycles that run several years for charitable giving. Getting revenue in quickly does not happen. I now have served on 5 non-profit boards and my time is much better spent providing direction than working directly for the non-profit. Most non-profits (there are exceptions) by definition are dysfunctional!

    • John Salveson says:

      Thanks for your comments Marc. Your experiences demonstrate the difference between the “hoped for” reality and the actual reality. I’m sure your board work is extremely valuable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*